ETF SCOUTFind. Compare. Invest.
← Back to News
Guides

What an ETF's fee includes, and what it leaves out

The cheapest Australian ETFs now charge 0.03% a year, so the fee is often the first number investors compare. It's a useful number, but not a complete one. Here's what the figure we show for each fund covers, and the costs that sit outside it.

ETF Scout Research Team
Published 4 min read

The short version

  • The fee ETF Scout shows is a fund's management fees and costs from its PDS: the issuer's own fee plus indirect costs, including fees charged by any fund it invests through.
  • Some ETFs are feeder funds that hold a fund listed overseas. In Global X's PDS, Global X Copper Miners ETF charges no management fee of its own: all of its 0.65% is the underlying fund's cost.
  • Where a fund is domiciled can cost more than its fee. Betashares estimates a US-domiciled global shares ETF left investors $241 to $419 a year worse off on $100,000, depending on their tax rate.
0.03%
the lowest fee among the funds we track, charged by A300, VTS and others
0.65%
WIRE's fee, all of it charged inside the US-listed fund it holds
$419
Betashares' estimate of the yearly after-tax cost of holding global shares through a US-domiciled ETF, on $100,000, for a pension-phase investor

Fees on broad index ETFs have fallen a long way. Among the funds ETF Scout tracks, the lowest is 0.03% a year, charged by a few funds, including Global X Australia 300 ETF (A300) and Vanguard Morningstar US Total Market Shares Index ETF (VTS). At that level, comparing funds on fee alone starts to miss the costs that aren't in the fee, and the ones that are in it but easy to overlook.

What the fee we show covers

Under ASIC's Regulatory Guide 97, every PDS sets out a fund's management fees and costs. That figure has two parts: the issuer's management fee, and indirect costs, which include the fees of any other fund the ETF invests through. ETF Scout shows that combined figure, labelled "Management fees and costs", rather than the headline management fee an issuer may quote on its fund page.

The difference matters most for funds that invest through other funds. For a fund that owns its shares directly, the two figures are usually close. For a fund that holds another fund, the headline fee can leave out most of the cost.

Feeder funds: a fee charged one level down

Some Australian ETFs don't buy their index's shares themselves. They hold units in a larger fund, often one listed overseas, and pass its returns on. Global X's feeder fund PDS covers three of these, each holding a Global X fund of the same theme listed on NYSE Arca in the US: Global X Copper Miners ETF (WIRE) holds COPX, Global X Uranium ETF (ATOM) holds URA, and Global X Defence Tech ETF (DTEC) holds SHLD.

The PDS shows a management fee of 0.00% for each of the three. Their whole cost is an indirect cost, charged inside the US fund. That's why ETF Scout lists WIRE at 0.65%, ATOM at 0.69% and DTEC at 0.50%: the cost an investor bears, not the Australian fund's own fee.

Where a fund is domiciled

A fund's legal home affects tax as well as fees. Betashares' analysis compares two ways of holding non-US global shares: an Australian-domiciled ETF that owns the shares directly, and a US-domiciled ETF. In the Australian fund, foreign withholding tax on dividends comes back to investors as a credit they can claim. In the US fund, those credits stay in the US, and US withholding tax is then charged again on the fund's own distributions.

On a $100,000 investment, Betashares estimates cash distributions of $2,372 a year through the US fund against $2,790 through the Australian one, plus $454 of withholding tax investors couldn't claim back. After tax, Betashares estimates the gap at $419 a year for a pension-phase investor and $241 for one on the top tax rate, which it says is more than a typical low-cost index fund's yearly fee.

Betashares makes two further points. A US-domiciled global fund may hold Australian shares, and investors don't get the franking credits on them. And an investor who doesn't lodge a W-8BEN form faces US withholding tax of 30%. A fund's PDS and fund page say where it's domiciled and whether it holds an offshore fund.

Securities lending

Many funds lend out the shares they hold, for a fee, to earn extra income. Global X's PDS, for example, says its underlying funds may lend securities to offset part of their costs, and that neither Global X nor the underlying fund's manager keeps any of the lending fees.

That income doesn't show up in the fee. ASIC's guide says a fund's fees and costs can't be reduced or offset by other income: the full cost must be disclosed. Two funds with the same fee can therefore deliver slightly different results, depending on how much lending income each earns and how it's shared between investors and the lending agent. The PDS sets out each fund's arrangements.

Costs outside the yearly fee

The yearly fee is charged inside the fund and shows up in its unit price, not as a separate bill. Trading costs come on top: the buy/sell spread, the gap between the price to buy and the price to sell, and your broker's fee. For someone who invests small amounts often, those can outweigh the difference between two low-cost funds' fees.

What it means for ETF investors

The fee is the one cost known in advance, and over many years it compounds. ETF Scout's fee cost calculator shows what any fund's management fees and costs add up to in dollars. For funds with similar fees, a fund's structure, its domicile and its spread can make a bigger difference, so it's worth reading the PDS's fees and tax sections before choosing between them.

Key takeaways

  1. 1The fee ETF Scout shows is the PDS figure for management fees and costs, which includes indirect costs such as the fees of an underlying fund.
  2. 2A feeder fund's own management fee can be zero while its total cost isn't: WIRE, ATOM and DTEC charge their whole fee through the US-listed funds they hold.
  3. 3Income from lending a fund's shares doesn't reduce the fee it discloses. ASIC requires fees and costs to be shown in full, not netted against other income.
  4. 4A fund's domicile affects how much of its dividend income reaches you, and whether you get franking credits on any Australian shares it holds.
  5. 5Buy/sell spreads and brokerage are paid when you trade, on top of the yearly fee.

Funds mentioned

FundManagement fees and costsYieldRatingCompare
Global X logoA300Global X Australia 300 ETF0.03%2.95%New fundCompare →
Vanguard logoVTSVanguard Morningstar US Total Market Shares Index ETF0.03%0.88%Compare →
Global X logoWIREGlobal X Copper Miners ETF0.65%3.51%Compare →
Global X logoATOMGlobal X Uranium ETF0.69%11.18%Compare →
Global X logoDTECGlobal X Defence Tech ETF0.50%3.15%New fundCompare →

Management fees and costs are p.a., from each fund's PDS. Yield is the trailing 12-month distribution yield.

Sources

  1. ASIC: Regulatory Guide 97, Disclosing fees and costs in PDSs and periodic statements
  2. Global X: Feeder Fund ETFs PDS (WIRE, ATOM, DTEC)
  3. Betashares: Watch out for tax drag when investing in foreign-domiciled ETFs
  4. Global X: Australia 300 ETF (A300) fund page
  5. Vanguard: US Total Market Shares Index ETF (VTS) fund page

Related tools

About us: ETF Scout Research Team

ETF Scout tracks every ETF listed on the ASX: fees, holdings, distributions and performance, sourced from issuers and the ASX.