Active Australian share funds fell short of the index again: what they cost
Most active Australian share funds fell short of the S&P/ASX 200 between January and June, S&P's latest scorecard shows. ETF Scout's fund data shows what investors pay for the attempt: a median 0.85% a year for active Australian share ETFs, against 0.30% for index and rules-based ones.
The short version
- S&P Dow Jones Indices' SPIVA Australia scorecard shows most active Australian share funds returning less than the S&P/ASX 200 over the six months to 30 June 2026.
- Of the 22 active Australian share ETFs we track, the median charges 0.85% a year, against 0.30% for the 42 index and rules-based ones.
- The index itself is concentrated: 50% of A200 sits in its 10 largest holdings.
S&P Dow Jones Indices publishes a scorecard twice a year comparing actively managed funds with their benchmarks. Its mid-2026 Australian edition found that most funds in its Australian general equity category returned less than the S&P/ASX 200 from January to June, and that the share falling short was higher still over five, ten and fifteen years.
What active funds charge
ETF Scout tracks 22 actively managed Australian share ETFs and 42 that follow an index or a set of rules. The median active fund charges 0.85% a year in management fees and costs; the median index or rules-based fund charges 0.30%. The cheapest broad index funds charge far less: Betashares Australia 200 ETF (A200) charges 0.04%.
Over time the difference compounds. Using ETF Scout's fee cost calculator, $100,000 growing at 7% a year before fees ends up $49,794 higher after 20 years in A200 than in Airlie Australian Share Fund - Active ETF (AASF), which charges 0.78%, if both earn the same return before fees.
What the index holds
An active manager has to beat an index that is itself concentrated. In ETF Scout's holdings data for A200, dated 4 Nov 2026, the 10 largest holdings make up 50% of the fund and the 20 largest 65%. A fund that holds less of those companies than the index will look very different from it, for better or worse.
What it means for ETF investors
A scorecard of past results doesn't say which active funds will do well next, and some active funds do beat their benchmark. What is known in advance is the fee. Comparing what a fund charges with a low-cost index alternative, and checking how much the two hold in common, shows how much an active fund has to add before its fee pays for itself.
Key takeaways
- 1S&P's SPIVA scorecard shows most active Australian share funds falling short of the S&P/ASX 200 between January and June.
- 2Active Australian share ETFs charge a median 0.85% a year, against 0.30% for index and rules-based ones.
- 3On $100,000 over 20 years at 7%, A200's fee leaves $49,794 more than AASF's, before any difference in returns.
- 450% of A200 is in its 10 largest holdings: that's the benchmark an active Australian share manager is trying to beat.
Funds mentioned
| Fund | Management fees and costs | Yield | Rating | Compare |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.04% | 3.29% | Compare → | ||
| AASFAirlie Australian Share Fund - Active ETF | 0.78% | — | — | Compare → |
Management fees and costs are p.a., from each fund's PDS. Yield is the trailing 12-month distribution yield.
Sources
Related tools
What a fund's management fees and costs add up to in dollars over time, compounding alongside your investment.
Fees, issuer, category and benchmark for up to 4 funds side by side.
See exactly how much 2-5 ETFs duplicate each other's underlying holdings.
Browse and filter every ASX ETF we track by category, issuer or fee.
ETF Scout tracks every ETF listed on the ASX: fees, holdings, distributions and performance, sourced from issuers and the ASX.
